Skip to main content

The Great Indian Divide - Part 1


Have you combed an Indian metro recently? What struck you as the blinding flash of the obvious?

The shining India? AND also in a few meters, a POOR nation caught in the slip stream of capitalism?

An economic divide? AND hence a cultural divide?

In short, did you notice the Class Conflict?

It’s the same class conflict or “alienation” that Karl Marx saw in the late 1800s. This has been a cause of my reluctance to move back to India. Because common sense and history tells that such class conflicts will result in social unrest and ugly revolutions as small as “mangalore bar attacks” (google it) to something as catastrophic as the French Revolution.

What is the cause for this great Indian divide?

The answer is “Knowledge Economy” and the “Knowledge Workers”. Let me dummify these terms first. Think of a line (like the poverty line) called the machine line. You are above the machine line if machines are your slaves. For example, a biotechnologist or a banker who uses a computer to get his job done. Notice that, it is not the machine but his knowledge that contributes to his productivity. Hence these are knowledge workers.

You are below the machine line if you are a slave to the machine. A machine operator in a cotton mill or a telephone receptionist, for example. Lets call them “task workers” or in Marx’s terminology, the proletariat. Notice that these people have to put long hours behind the machines for their productivity.

Without getting into much history, I have to tell you that NOW is the era of knowledge. And knowledge workers command a premium naturally. And the task workers gets alienated and exploited. Because no matter how many hours he puts in behind a machine, he is dispensable and hence a poor pay (compared to that of the knowledge workers).

Hence the class conflict!

So is a revolution inevitable in any near future in India?
Labels:

Comments

  1. aasamyJune 18, 2009 at 2:33 PM

    And?

    You better finish this quickly before I write something nasty... and no.. it cannot be wash you hands with your favourite soap.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Raja SPJune 18, 2009 at 3:03 PM

    Hahha. Sure, i have my conclusion. But its a open ended question and I am looking for your comments and opinion on the question.

    ReplyDelete
  3. UnknownJune 18, 2009 at 11:24 PM

    well ..I am sure you are thinking in line with what you are reading.appreciate it. .But who said the "proletariat" are dispensable. "Domestic helpers" / "baby sitters" who are obviously not knowledge workers are the most indispensable these days :)) Anyway hear me out mate " NO ONE IS INDISPENSABLE"... that is reality !! having said that question for you -> So you expecting ugly revolutions and not relocating to India..? Impressive !!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Raja SPJune 19, 2009 at 11:07 AM

    Vino, I have reached a stage in reading where I don't consider anyone's words as absolute truths (whether it comes from Peter Drucker or Adhi Shankarar). I only accept the loudest words (which are mine. hehe).

    Service workers (maids/baby sitters) or Task workers (factory workers) are dispensable because if one goes, you can train another in few days. But it takes 5 years to teach and 2 years to train to produce a decent building architect. That is where the difference is.

    Having said that I agree with your comment "NO ONE IS INDISPENSABLE". This man called Frederick Winslow Taylor proved in 1870s that there is no such thing as a skilled work. His is a scientific method of breaking down work into small components which any non-skilled worker can manage. Assembly lines come from his theory. He lead to the demolition of craftsmen who kept skills as secrets. Those days even making wine barrels was a secret craft and i read in the news that there is only one "barrel master" left in the world now. Rapid industrialization. Knowledge work will also reach this stage soon and then such workers become truly dispensable. Anyway more on this subject in the next post.

    My thinking on the plausible ugly revolution - also later.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Birthdays and Facebook

I read about a guy who had 400+ friends in Facebook. One day he woke up as a curious little wanker and wondered if he is really that sociable. So he organized a party and sent invitations to all his contacts over Facebook. 50% confirmed and another 20% were tentative. He was delighted - that’s one hell of a response, actually. The real day came. Our man waited at the venue, which happened to be a popular joint, but no single soul turned up. An hour later, one woman came but she also left in the next 30 minutes. He had 400 friends and yet he ended up drinking alone that night. So the question to ponder is how close are our virtual worlds to the reality? . But my case was quite not as somber. Yesterday was my birthday. Facebook reminded of it to a whole lot of my gang. Some of them have never wished me in decades and some are new. How exciting! So here is my big thanks to all my dear friends for the wishes over calls, sms and facebook. You made me feel special. Special thanks to cutie p...
9 comments
Read more

A Date - Part 1

“Good Morning. How is everything? Did you manage to have an early breakfast date with yourself?” I was on the bed in a hotel room in Jakarta when that SMS woke me up. I only managed to get a very few hours of sleep that night. Even in that, my mind went churning non-stop on some meaningless, unconnected things. I was literally aware of all that turmoil in the half sleep, twisting and tossing through it. Back to the SMS. All the SMS I get usually are with a single consistent purpose - my colleagues trying to find my whereabouts. Note - none of them is a hot babe. (This is altogether a different topic - how come no hot chick in this whole damn world manages to become an IT architect!!) Oh, for a change, I do occasionally get some irritating marketing campaigns. So, it is not a wonder that this message sprang me awake like a Maasai Warrior. (Maasai are an African tribe famous for their ability to rise from the deepest sleep to a state of total combat readiness in a matter of seconds)...
2 comments
Read more

What is my utilitarianism?

I am a utilitarian. Do you know how hard it is to live as a utilitarian these days? You often get mocked in closer circles. In the pretentious places, you are looked down upon. You are generally pushed to feel like a flying swine - strange, curious and out of place. The problem is the word ‘utility’ in it. The commoners derive a shallow meaning that it is utility before happiness. Utility before pleasure. Stretching it a bit, they think that a utilitarian denies pleasures, leads a boring life of a miser, does not appreciate finer things in life and is generally a philistine. But utilitarianism is exactly opposite of that. I will be a damned liar if I declare that I am holy and have renounced all the pleasures. The tricky thing, and here in lies a great secret about the art of living, is to understand what pleasure really is. I think there is such a thing as ‘ supreme ’ pleasure. And by virtue of the existence of a supreme pleasure, there are also ‘ inferio...
2 comments
Read more